In most states today your employer or prospective employer can use information from your credit report to make employment decisions, like whether to hire, fire, or promote you. Some states currently prohibit this practice, but not all states, and not for all professions. It is important for you to know what your rights are, and what an employer's obligations are when it comes to credit reports. For example, an employer must get your permission before obtaining your credit report. For more information about how your credit report may be used in employment decisions, read below:
4. My employer says I have given permission for a credit check, but I didn't recall granting them permission. They showed me the form, and it was buried deep in a bunch of other text on my application form. Is that adequate to show my approval?
5. I granted my employer permission to check my credit when I was hired several years ago, but it was not checked at that time. Now, a new manager has decided that everyone's credit should be checked. Does my employer have to give me notice that it is now checking credit reports?
Possibly. Many employers now use the same credit files used by credit card providers and mortgage brokers to determine whether you are the most financially stable and reliable employee for the job. Credit agencies can share your information with those who have a legitimate business need for the information. An employer using your report to determine your eligibility for "employment, promotion, reassignment or retention" is therefore entitled to access. Whether an employer can run a credit check will depend on what state you live in.
The Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA) governs the use of credit information in the employment setting. The FCRRCA is designed to ensure that you are aware of and agree to your credit report being used for employment purposes, and that you are notified promptly if information in a credit report may be used in a negative employment decision. If you are job hunting, you may want to check your credit report with each of the three major credit reporting agencies (Experian, Trans Union, and Equifax). You are entitled to a free copy of your report from each agency every twelve months. For more information, see the official website to obtain your free report at annualcreditreport.com.
Although employers must request your permission before obtaining your credit report, the FCRA does not prevent employers from denying you a job or promotion, or even terminating you on the basis of your negative credit--even if your credit report is incorrect. Some employers have even used an employee's credit report to find out whether the employee was looking for work with other companies, since the credit report lists all companies who have recently accessed the employee's credit.
However, 11 states have passed legislation that limits an employer's ability to use your credit report in the employment setting. Those states are: California, Colorado, Connecticut, Delaware, Hawaii, Illinois, Maryland, Nevada, Oregon, Vermont, and Washington. In most of those states, it is now an illegal employment practice for an employer to use a credit report in making employment related decisions. There are exceptions in most states that allow certain employers to use your credit report,, including financial institutions, public safety officers, and where a credit report could be related to your job duties. Currently there are 34 bills under consideration which would place restrictions on credit considerations for employment. Additionally, some localities such as New York City, have implemented bands on credit checks for potential employees.
Possibly. Again, this will depend on which state you live in. Under federal law, with your permission, the employer can use the credit check as one of the factors in determining the best candidate for the job. It does not matter whether or not the job has anything to do with handling money, juggling budgets, or similar tasks for which credit information might relate more directly to your fitness for the job.
However, if you live in any of the 11 states in which legislation concerning credit checks has been passed (California, Colorado, Connecticut, Delaware, Hawaii, Illinois, Maryland, Nevada, Oregon, Vermont, and Washington), your employer may not use this information to deny you a promotion.
Yes. The FCRA requires that you give written permission before your employer can access your credit report. An employer who does not obtain your permission before requesting your report has violated the FCRA.
No. The written disclosure that your employer will seek credit information about you must be contained within a separate document used solely for that purpose, with a separate authorization signature required. It cannot be buried in a job application or employee handbook.
No. Once you have given written permission, the employer is not legally required to give any additional notice before actually obtaining the report from a credit reporting agency. Even if you had good credit when you started work, your employment could be at risk if your employer decides to check your credit later, and your credit rating has declined in the meantime.
Without your permission, your employer cannot check your credit report, but your refusal may leave your employer thinking that you have something to hide. Under federal law, there is nothing in that situation that protects you from being terminated or not getting hired by a prospective employer. However, 11 states (California, Colorado, Connecticut, Delaware, Hawaii, Illinois, Maryland, Nevada, Oregon, Vermont, and Washington) have passed legislation that protect against such discrimination.
Your employer can technically use any information in your credit report any way it wants, as there is no protection against losing your job on the basis of information in your credit report. However, before your employer rejects you for a job based "in whole or in part" on something in your credit report, the employer must give you a copy of the report before turning you down and written instructions on challenging the accuracy of the report. For more information, see question 8.
The FCRA's notice provision is supposed to give you some opportunity to work with the credit bureaus to ensure that all information in the report is accurate--which you should already be doing if you know there is a problem. Hopefully, your credit file will reflect that you were the victim of identity theft, if that is the case, and your employer will be reasonable and not use that information against you.
However, your employer does not have to give you time to get the information investigated and corrected, and cannot be held liable for taking action against you due to information in your credit report, even if the information is erroneous.
For more information, see the FTC publication: How To Dispute Credit Report Errors.
The FCRA requires the three major credit reporting agencies, Equifax Experian, and TransUnion, to provide you with a free credit report once every 12 months. It is important to check your credit reports once a year because some studies show that nearly one-third of credit reports have mistaken information on them. You don't need to individually contact all three credit reporters. To review the various ways you can request all three free reports visit the Federal Trade Commission website.
Yes, there are steps you can take to correct mistakes on your credit reports. The first thing you need to do is get a copy of your credit reports, as explained above. Next, write a letter to the credit reporting agency that you believe has recorded a mistake, include a copy of your report and all documents that help prove what you explained in your letter. Remember to request that the item be removed or corrected. Keep copies and verification that you sent the letter, like a return receipt, certified mail receipt, or copy of the envelope. Additionally, the reporting agencies are required to review your report and your allegation of error. If they agree a mistake was made, you may request that they send the correct information to all individuals that requested your credit report. Finally you need to write the organization that has provide the credit companies with the incorrect information and explain to them that they are reporting mistaken information to the credit reporting agencies and how you would like them to resolve the issue.
In theory yes, however it is easy for employers to avoid this requirement by finding some other basis to deny you the job. Before your employer rejects you for a job based "in whole or in part" on something in your credit report, the employer must give you a "pre-adverse action disclosure," consisting of:
However, it is difficult to determine whether an employer has been influenced by your credit report and/or violated the law, if the employer gives some other legitimate reason for the decision.
If your employer has decided to take adverse action against you, such as firing you or denying you a promotion, or a reassignment, because of your credit report, it must provide you with an "adverse action notice," containing the following information:
However, as noted above, your employer may give another legitimate reason, or may not give a reason at all, once they are aware of the negative information in your credit report. Even though the employer is supposed to give you the information listed above if information in your credit report influenced the employment decision in whole or in part, it is difficult to prove whether the employer followed the law when making its decision.
Under the FCRA, a current or prospective employer cannot be sued for defamation, invasion of privacy, or negligence regarding its use of the information in the credit report, unless the information was false and provided with malice or willful intent to injure you. This is a very high legal standard and unlikely to be met in most cases.
However, an employer who violates the FCRA can be sued for actual damages, court costs, and reasonable attorney's fees, and in the case of a willful violation, can be sued for punitive damages. The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) can also sue employers for civil penalties of up to $2500 per violation. Some states may also have laws which protect you in this situation.
As mentioned above, under federal law, the FCRA does not contain any remedies for individuals denied jobs on the basis of information from their credit reports, even if the negative information used is inaccurate. If the information in your credit report is inaccurate, you should make it a priority to get it corrected. If it is accurate, then you may need to find a different employer who does not check credit reports for all or any jobs.
If you think that your employer used your credit report as a smokescreen for another form of retaliation or discrimination, or has used a negative credit report against some employees but not other similarly situated employees, then you may want to consult with an attorney to see if you have other grounds for challenging the employer's action.
However, if you live in a state that has passed legislation concerning credit checks in the employment setting (California, Colorado, Connecticut, Delaware, Hawaii, Illinois, Maryland, Nevada, Oregon, Vermont, and Washington), you should contact a lawyer to find out more about your rights.
FTC Publication: Negative Credit Can Squeeze a Job Search
© 2019 Workplace Fairness